Roll for judges - august september (general office roll)

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF
SOUTH AFRICA
IN DIE HOOGSTE HOF VAN APPèL VAN
SUID-AFRIKA
AUGUST / SEPTEMBER 2013
FINAL ROLL
(28 May 2013)
Thursday 15 August 2013

COURT A
10.
Eskom Holdings SOC Ltd v Hitachi Power Africa (Pty) Ltd & another
139/13 (GSJ)

1 3 11 15 18
MTHIYANE AP BRAND JA SHONGWE JA MAJIEDT JA PETSE JA
COURT B
9.
Association of Meat Importers and Exporters & 20 others v International
Trade Administration Commission & 57 others
769, 770 & 771/12 (GNP)

4 5 14 16 20
NUGENT JA LEWIS JA THERON JA WALLIS JA SALDULKER JA (DAY ONE)
Jeffery Israel Levenstein v The State
890/12 (GSJ)

8 10 12 19 24
CACHALIA JA BOSIELO JA LEACH JA WILLIS JA MEYER AJA Friday 16 August 2013

COURT A
19.
Shawn Mark Fegen & others v Douglas Mphakathi
348/12 (ECG)
2 13 17 21 22
NAVSA ADP TSHIQI JA PILLAY JA VAN DER MERWE AJA SWAIN AJA
COURT B
22. Nedbank Ltd v Ronald Mendelow & another NNO
686/12 (GNP)

LEWIS JA MAYA JA MALAN JA SHONGWE JA ZONDI AJA (DAY TWO)
Jeffery Israel Levenstein v The State
890/12 (GSJ)

8 10 12 19 24
CACHALIA JA BOSIELO JA LEACH JA WILLIS JA MEYER AJA Monday 19 August 2013

COURT A
5.
Jacobus Petrus Fourie & another NNO v Edkins Graham Vernon
740/12 (GSJ)

1 7 11 13 23
MTHIYANE AP MAYA JA SHONGWE JA TSHIQI JA ZONDI AJA COURT B
49.
The Competition Commission v Yara (South Africa)(Pty) Ltd & others
784/12 (CAC)

BRAND JA NUGENT JA MALAN JA PETSE JA SALDULKER JA
COURT C
15.
The State v Phakamani A Nkunkuma & others
101/13 (ECP)

6 10 14 16 17
PONNAN JA BOSIELO JA THERON JA WALLIS JA PILLAY JA Tuesday 20 August 2013

COURT A
14.
Johannes Tlhoalela Mafokate v The Law Society of the Northern
Provinces
786/12 (GNP)

1 5 11 16 23
MTHIYANE AP LEWIS JA SHONGWE JA WALLIS JA ZONDI AJA
COURT B
20.
PriceWaterhouseCoopers Inc & others v National Potato Co-operative
Ltd & another
451 & 468/12 (GNP)

2 3 13 15 22
NAVSA ADP BRAND JA TSHIQI JA MAJIEDT JA SWAIN AJA COURT C
17.
Quartermark Investments (Pty) Ltd v Pinky Mkhwanazi & another
768/12 (GSJ)

7 10 14 17 18
MAYA JA BOSIELO JA THERON JA PILLAY JA PETSE JA Wednesday 21 August 2013

COURT A
8.
Camworth Technologies Ltd v Videx Wire Products (Pty) Ltd t/a Videx
Mining Products
702/12 (GNP)

4 6 10 16 22
NUGENT JA PONNAN JA BOSIELO JA WALLIS JA SWAIN AJA
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 22 August 2013

COURT A
11.
Business Partners Ltd v Yellow Star Properties (Pty) Ltd
815/12 (KZD)


COURT B
18. Gerhardus Francois Rossouw NO & another v Land en Landbou
Ontwikkelingsbank van Suid Afrika
794/12 (GNP)

3 12 15 21 24
BRAND JA LEACH JA MAJIEDT JA VAN DER MERWE AJA MEYER AJA
COURT C
7.
Absa Bank Ltd v Bhekani Ernest Mkhize & another; Absa Bank Ltd v
Sean Chetty; Absa Bank Ltd v Dalubuhle Xolanie Mlipha
716/12 (KZD)

5 6 11 20 23
LEWIS JA PONNAN JA SHONGWE JA SALDULKER JA ZONDI AJA Friday 23 August 2013

COURT A
4.
Solenta Aviation (Pty) Ltd v Aviation@Work (Pty) Ltd
754/12 (GNP)
1 6 13 19 24

MTHIYANE AP PONNAN JA TSHIQI JA WILLIS JA MEYER AJA Andre Herholdt v Nedbank Ltd
701/12 (Labour Court Appeal)
4 8 11 16 22

NUGENT JA CACHALIA JA SHONGWE JA WALLIS JA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
3.
Sandile Bokolo v The State
483/12 (WCC)
9 14 15 21 23

MALAN JA THERON JA MAJIEDT JA VAN DER MERWE AJA ZONDI AJA Monday 26 August 2013

COURT A
16.
T H Restaurants (Pty) Ltd v Rana Pazza (Pty) Ltd & others
859/12 (WCC)
2 5 17 20 21

NAVSA ADP LEWIS JA PILLAY JA SALDULKER JA VAN DER MERWE AJA
COURT B
33.
Bayerische
Aktiengesellschaft
Grandmark
International (Pty) Ltd
722/12 (GNP)
3 4 8 16 22

Kevin Ndivhuwo Managa & others v The State
118/13 (LP)
6 9 13 18 23
PONNAN JA MALAN JA TSHIQI JA PETSE JA ZONDI AJA Tuesday 27 August 2013

COURT A
36.
Isabel Joyce Florence v The Government of the Republic of South Africa
550/12 (LCC)
NAVSA ADP NUGENT JA MALAN JA TSHIQI JA SALDULKER JA
COURT B
30.
MEDX (Randburg) (Pty) Limited v Andrew Shaun Branfield
676/12 (GSJ)

3 7 16 18 23
BRAND JA MAYA JA WALLIS JA PETSE JA ZONDI AJA
COURT C
59.
George Talbot Spencer & others v Xolisa Kennedy Memani & another
675/12 (KZD)
5 6 17 19 24
LEWIS JA PONNAN JA PILLAY JA WILLIS JA MEYER AJA Wednesday 28 August 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 29 August 2013

COURT A
24.
Axal Properties 2 CC & another v Hendrik Nicolaas Kotzé
712/12 (GSJ)
1 3 13 15 19

MTHIYANE AP BRAND JA TSHIQI JA MAJIEDT JA WILLIS JA
COURT B
29.
Stewart Graham Hewitt v The Director of Public Prosecutions, KwaZulu-
Natal
975/12 (KZD)

6 9 11 17 22
PONNAN JA MALAN JA SHONGWE JA PILLAY JA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
52.
Nothozamile Pumla Mbaba v Nobelusi Mbaba & others
474/12 (ECM)

7 12 14 18 20
MAYA JA LEACH JA THERON JA PETSE JA SALDULKER JA Friday 30 August 2013

COURT A
37.
Minister of Agriculture and Land Affairs & another v Carola Maria de
Klerk & others
747/12 (GNP)

2 8 15 21 24
NAVSA ADP CACHALIA JA MAJIEDT JA VAN DER MERWE AJA MEYER AJA
COURT B
41.
South African National Roads Agency Limited v The Toll Collect
Consortium & another
796/12 (KZD)

4 10 16 18 22
NUGENT JA BOSIELO JA WALLIS JA PETSE JA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
44.
Jeffrey Khathutshelo Matshivha v The State
656/12 (LT)

6 7 11 13 23
Monday 2 September 2013
Capricorn Beach Home Owners Association v H E S Potgieter t/a
Nilands & another
752/12 (WCC)

1 7 16 21 22
MTHIYANE AP MAYA JA WALLIS JA VAN DER MERWE AJA SWAIN AJA
COURT B
32.
National Health Laboratory Service v Mariana Magdalena Lloyd-Jansen
van Vuuren
667/12 (GSJ)

2 11 14 18 20
NAVSA ADP SHONGWE JA THERON JA PETSE JA SALDULKER JA Tuesday 3 September 2013

COURT A
43.
Humbulani Makatu v The State
612/12 (LT)

2 7 10 17 24
NAVSA ADP MAYA JA BOSIELO JA PILLAY JA MEYER AJA COURT B
57.
The Minister of Home Affairs & others v Scalabrini Centre, Cape Town &
others
735/12 (WCC)

4 5 14 16 19
NUGENT JA LEWIS JA THERON JA WALLIS JA WILLIS JA
COURT C
45.
Azwifaneli Rasirubu v The State
651/12 (LT)

6 12 13 21 23
PONNAN JA LEACH JA TSHIQI JA VAN DER MERWE AJA ZONDI AJA Wednesday 4 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 5 September 2013

COURT A
25.
Pieter Paul le Roux & another v Paul Steenkamp Nel & another
246/13 (NCK)


COURT B
28.
The Member of the Executive Council for Finance and Economic
Development, Kwa-Zulu Natal v Masifundisane Training and Development
College CC
606/12 (KZP)

5 6 13 16 22
LEWIS JA PONNAN JA TSHIQI JA WALLIS JA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
48.
Vamile Michael Mchunu & another v The State
Mahadulula Thinashaka v The State
825/12 (KZP) & 065/13 (LP)

7 10 11 17 23
MAYA JA BOSIELO JA SHONGWE JA PILLAY JA ZONDI AJA Friday 6 September 2013

COURT A
13.
Minister of Police & another v Ashwell du Plessis
666/12 (GSJ)

2 6 10 17 24
NAVSA ADP PONNAN JA BOSIELO JA PILLAY JA MEYER AJA The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration & others v
The Law Society of the Northern Provinces
005/13 (GNP)

4 9 16 21 22
NUGENT JA MALAN JA WALLIS JA VAN DER MERWE AJA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
55.
Tshepo Bosielo & another v The State
071/13 (NWM)

5 7 15 18 20
LEWIS JA MAYA JA MAJIEDT JA PETSE JA SALDULKER JA Monday 9 September 2013

COURT A
54.
Summit Warehousing (Pty) Ltd v Thuthabantu Properties CC
648/12 (KZP)

1 3 11 18 23
MTHIYANE AP BRAND JA SHONGWE JA PETSE JA ZONDI AJA
COURT B
6.
The Minister of Safety and Security v Bonisile John Katise
328/12 (ECG)


COURT C
26.
Bongani Gama v The State
127/13 (GNP)

9 14 15 20 21
MALAN JA THERON JA MAJIEDT JA SALDULKER JA VAN DER MERWE AJA Tuesday 10 September 2013

COURT A
53.
Sandra Lee de Haas v Garry John Fromentin & others
499/12 (GNP)

1 14 18 21 23
MTHIYANE AP THERON JA PETSE JA VAN DER MERWE AJA ZONDI AJA
COURT B
38.
Matsheng Jacob Chake v The State
205/13 (NWHC)

2 12 13 20 22
NAVSA ADP LEACH JA TSHIQI JA SALDULKER JA SWAIN AJA
COURT C
46.
Dexgroup (Pty) Ltd v Trustco Group International (Pty) Ltd & others
687/12 (GSJ)

6 9 15 16 17
PONNAN JA MALAN JA MAJIEDT JA WALLIS JA PILLAY JA Wednesday 11 September 2013

COURT A
34.
Karl Meinert Pfister v Road Accident Fund
711/12 (FB)

3 12 15 17 24
BRAND JA LEACH JA MAJIEDT JA PILLAY JA MEYER AJA
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 12 September 2013

COURT A
51.
Stabilpave (Pty) Ltd v The South African Revenue Services
615/12 (GNP)

3 5 10 14 24
BRAND JA LEWIS JA BOSIELO JA THERON JA MEYER AJA
COURT B
40.
National Union of Metalworkers of South Africa & others v Abancedisi
Labour Services
857/12 (LAC)
7 9 11 17 20

COURT C
47.
Paul Casey & another v Firstrand Bank Ltd
608/12 (GSJ)

2 13 18 19 22
Friday 13 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Monday 16 September 2013

COURT A
50.
Caesarstone Sdot-Yam Ltd v The World of Marble and Granite & others
1 7 14 16 21
COURT B
42.
Christoph Bornman v National Credit Regulator
798/12 (GNP)

COURT C
31.
CA Focus CC v Village Freezer t/a Ashmel Spar
731/12 (ECG)

8 12 15 18 19
CACHALIA JA LEACH JA MAJIEDT JA PETSE JA Tuesday 17 September 2013

COURT A
2.
Road Accident Fund v Maryna Magdalena van Zyl
635/12 (GSJ)

2 9 13 20 21
NAVSA ADP MALAN JA TSHIQI JA SALDULKER JA
COURT B
21.
Smith Mining Equipment (Pty) Ltd v The Commissioner: South African
Revenue Service
728/12 (GNP)

4 5 10 16 22
COURT C
1.
Ethekwini Municipality v The South African Municipal Workers Union &
others
442/11 (LAC)

6 8 12 15 19
PONNAN JA CACHALIA JA LEACH JA MAJIEDT JA Wednesday 18 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 19 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Friday 20 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Monday 23 September 2013
COURT B
COURT C

Tuesday 24 September 2013
P U B L I C H O L I D A Y
Wednesday 25 September 2013
(DAY ONE)
Opposition to Urban Tolling Alliance & 3 others v The South African
Roads Agency Ltd & 6 others
90/2013

3 4 18 21 22

COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 26 September 2013
(DAY TWO)
Opposition to Urban Tolling Alliance & 3 others v The South African
Roads Agency Ltd & 6 others
90/2013

3 4 18 21 22
COURT B
COURT C

Thursday 26 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Friday 27 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Monday 30 September 2013

COURT A
COURT B
COURT C

Source: http://www.phinc.co.za/Publications/Roll%20for%20Judges%20-%20August%20%20September%20(General%20Office%20Roll).pdf